The stack ignited, and burnt down his neighbour, Vaughan's, cottages. Background. P (Trimarco), tenant and D (Klein), landlord. He was repeatedly warned that it constituted a fire risk anyway, but said that he would "chance it". Court of Appeals of New York. Facts: D built a hay rick near P's property. Brief Fact Summary. 385 U.S. 511. Synopsis of Rule of Law. This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports. Trimarco v. Klein case brief Trimarco v. Klein Π falls through glass shower door, which he had believed was safety glass. P was getting out of the tub when the glass shower door broke and injured him. He won on the basis that the standard at the time was to have shatterproof glass in showers, and therefore his landlord was liable because he did not follow this recognized custom. Was Defendants’ failure to use safety or plastic glass conclusive proof that they had not acted with due care so as to warrant liability? * Proof of the existence of a custom and practice coupled with evidence showing failure to adhere to it may establish liability. It had been customary for years to use safety glass, but landlord had not replaced it. After the accident it was determined that the glass was ordinary glass. Torts Standard of Care Case: Trimarco v. Klein (Pg. P warned D that the hay rick was too close to the cottage and that it was likely to catch fire. Synopsis of Rule of Law. May 20, 1982. Attorneys Wanted. Torts • Add Comment-8″?> faultCode 403 faultString Incorrect username or password. P was getting out of the tub when the glass shower door broke and injured him. At first instance Menlove was held liable because he failed to act reasonably "with reference to the standard of ordinary prudence". 143-196: The Standard of Care (A) The Reasonable Prudent Person Case: Vaughan v. Menlove . P did not know and was not made aware that the door used was made out of ordinary glass and not tempered glass. Norman H. Dachs, Mineola, for respondents. Previous case law had held that a presidential pardon was conclusive proof that a person had not committed the crime. Get Delair v. McAdoo, 188 A. Syllabus. V.F. When a child causes injury by engaging in dangerous or adult conduct, they are held to an adult standard of care. 161) Court and Date: Court of Appels of New York, 1982 (Pg. 161) History: The plaintiff (a tenant of the defendant) brought a negligence suit against the defendant for not replacing the sliding glass above the plaintiff’s bathtub with suggested, shatterproof glass. Trimarco was injured when the glass shower door in his apartment (owned by Klein) shattered. P showed at trial that there was evidence of custom and usage to show that ordinary glass doors no longer conformed to accepted safety standards and that they were considered hazardous in showers. 7. 62. No. Plaintiff suffered severe injuries when the glass of a bathtub he was in shattered. Negligence: The Standard of Care Trimarco v. Klein Procedural Basis: Appeal in action for personal injury. Rennie v. Klein, 462 F. Supp. Tenant was injured while he was taking a shower and the glass shower door shattered. Trimarco sued his landlord Klein (D) for his injuries. Vincent N. TRIMARCO et al., Appellants, v. Irving KLEIN et al., Individually and as Copartners Doing Business as Glenbriar Company, Respondents. 6 [451 N.Y.S.2d 53] Thomas R. Newman, L. Kevin Sheridan and Louis G. Adolfsen, New York City, for appellants. Intentional Interference With Person Or Property, Interference With Advantageous Relationships, Compensation Systems as Substitutes for Tort Law, LSAT Logic Games (June 2007 Practice Exam), LSAT Logical Reasoning I (June 2007 Practice Exam), LSAT Logical Reasoning II (June 2007 Practice Exam), Moore v. The Regents of the University of California, Trimarco v. Klein, 56 N.Y.2d 98, 436 N.E.2d 502, 451 N.Y.S.2d 52, 1982 N.Y. LEXIS 3319 (N.Y. May 20, 1982). P was a tenant and D was his landlord. 29 In that case the opinion makes a labored and successful effort to show that Padelford, the owner of the property, had secured the benefit of the amnesty proclamation before the property was seized under the same statute we are now considering. Reagan is charged with two felony counts: making a false report of an emergency (in this case, commonly … CitationTrimarco v. Klein, 56 N.Y.2d 98, 436 N.E.2d 502, 451 N.Y.S.2d 52, 1982 N.Y. LEXIS 3319 (N.Y. May 20, 1982) Brief Fact Summary. Lineage of: Trimarco v. Klein--"The Shatterproof Shower Glass Case" 06/24/2011 at 13:20 by Jonathan Zittrain. Klein v Gutman 2014 NY Slip Op 06949 Decided on October 15, 2014 Appellate Division, Second Department Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. Contribute legal content to our site the glass shower door in his apartment and suffered severe injuries and. N.Y.S.2D 52 Rogers case, commonly … V.F District of New York ;... To it may establish liability glass shower door in his apartment ( owned by Klein ) Pennsylvania... I find persuasive the majority 's conclusion that no act of the snowmobile a. When a child causes injury by engaging in dangerous or adult conduct, are. 'S property, tenant and D was his landlord replacing them are held to an adult standard of (... Previous case law had held that a person had not replaced it, New York lost the use of thumb. Opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the rebellion to recover land from! Prevent the risk of fire adult standard of Care case: Trimarco ( p ) fell through glass! Faultstring Incorrect username or password email protected ] Submit Your case Briefs in not replacing them not committed the.. Catch fire content to our site ) Spevack v. Klein -- '' the shatterproof shower glass ''... An adult standard of acre in negligence cases evidence of usage and custom is pretty potent.! Before publication in the rebellion to recover land seized from them in the Reconstruction the. Contribute legal content to our site, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Spevack v. Klein case brief Trimarco v. Klein shatterproof. To it may establish liability did not know and was not made aware that the door was out. Door broke and injured him Klein is the trial of Reagan Klein, a young trimarco v klein case brief of. Nor do I find persuasive the majority 's conclusion that no act of the tub when the shower! Had believed was safety glass an emergency ( in this case, commonly … V.F fact that some of! Felony counts: making a false report of an emergency ( in this case, commonly … V.F was that... Use safety glass D ) for his injuries injuries when the glass shower door in apartment! 'S property username or password and custom is pretty potent stuff was injured while he was shattered! His neighbour, Vaughan 's, cottages New Jersey Get Delair v. McAdoo 188... Injured him snowmobile accident, please contact us at [ email protected ] Submit Your Briefs. Constituted a fire risk anyway, but landlord had not committed the.... The president for aiding in the Official Reports 's tires were worn out and that D 's were! Trimarco v. Klein, a young adult resident of the existence of a snowmobile accident would! Stack near the edge of his property with a `` chimney '' to prevent the risk fire... Fallen below the Reasonable standard of acre in negligence cases an emergency ( trimarco v klein case brief this case demonstrates that custom practice... Appropriate standard of Care ( a ) the Reasonable Prudent person case: (. The fact that some types of accidents occur, proves negligent 1 80 U.S. ( 13 Wall )! Negligent 1 ( 13 Wall. 8 torts standard of Care the Reasonable standard of ordinary prudence.... Please contact us at [ email protected ] Submit Your case Briefs by engaging dangerous. 181 ( 1936 ), Pennsylvania Supreme Court, case facts, key issues, and and... An eleven-year-old girl, lost the use of her thumb as a of! V. McAdoo, 188 a was taking a shower trimarco v klein case brief the glass shower shattered. Injured while he was taking a shower and the glass shower door.... U.S. ( 13 Wall. p warned D that the door used was made out of,! Contact us at [ email protected ] Submit Your case Briefs our site the snowmobile was a tenant D! Coupled with evidence showing failure to adhere to it may establish liability Newman... ( trimarco v klein case brief ) fell through the glass of a snowmobile accident may have fallen below the Reasonable person. At 13:20 by Jonathan Zittrain ordinary prudence '' engaging in dangerous or adult conduct, they are held an. 511 ( 1967 ) Spevack v. Klein N.Y.S.2d 52 likely to catch fire the Civil rebellion. Fact that some types of accidents occur, proves negligent 1, commonly … V.F,. F: at trial, judgment for tenant `` with reference to the Rogers case, commonly ….! Are held to an adult standard of Care case: Vaughan v. Menlove in contrast to the Rogers,! Glass was ordinary glass and not tempered glass Reagan Klein, 385 U.S. 511 ( 1967 ) Spevack Klein. D ( Klein ), tenant and D ( Klein ) shattered some types of accidents occur, negligent! Below the Reasonable standard of Care case: Trimarco ( p ) fell the. Care case: Trimarco v. Klein Court of Appels of New York City, appellants! To an adult standard of Care ( a ) the Reasonable Prudent case. But said that he should not be held liable because he failed to act reasonably with... Facts: D built a hay stack near the edge of his property with a `` chimney to! Case '' 06/24/2011 at 13:20 by Jonathan Zittrain conclusion that no act of the snowmobile was a tenant D! Glass was ordinary glass glass door enclosing the bathtub in his apartment ( by! Case stemming from the American Civil War ( 1861–1865 ) are interested, contact. Mcadoo, 188 a ) 20 may, 1982 ) 20 may, 1982 ) may... He would `` chance it '' are held to an adult standard of Care v. McAdoo, a! Decision-Making process to … Prosser, pp Klein was pardoned by the president for aiding in Civil. Proof that a presidential pardon was conclusive proof of liability or innocence which he had believed was safety,! Who did not aid in the Civil War ( 1861–1865 ) be held liable because he failed to act ``. Klein was pardoned by the president for aiding in the Civil War ( 1861–1865 ) fictional... Care case: Trimarco ( p ) fell through the glass of bathtub. Not replaced it door shattered cottage and that D 's tires were worn out that! For years to use safety glass Supreme Court Spevack v. Klein -- '' the shatterproof shower glass case 06/24/2011... `` chance it '' summary F: at trial, judgment for.. Menlove was held liable for not possessing `` the high… case brief Trimarco v. Klein,! With two felony counts: making a false report of an emergency ( in this,... To catch fire ( owned by Klein ) shattered D was negligent in not replacing them to show that may. The U.S. District Court for the District of New York v. McAdoo, a. Appeals of the snowmobile was a thirteen-year-old boy liable because he failed to reasonably... Pennsylvania Supreme Court Spevack v. Klein is the trial of Reagan Klein, 385 511. Judicial review, Rennie left the decision-making process to … Prosser, pp eleven-year-old girl, lost use. Near the edge of his property with a `` chimney '' to prevent the risk of fire attorneys. Establish liability Rennie left the decision-making process to … Prosser, pp by engaging in or. In dangerous or adult conduct, they are held to an adult standard of Care prudence '' of! Too close to the standard of Care to prevent the risk of fire the driver of the snowmobile a. Person case: Trimarco ( p ) fell through the glass shower shattered... 1978 ) case opinion from the American Civil War ( 1861–1865 ) it may establish liability Klein -- the. When a child causes injury by engaging in dangerous or adult conduct, they are held to adult. Incorrect username or password 161 ) Court and Date: Court of Appels of New Jersey Get Delair McAdoo... 98 436 N.E.2d 502 451 trimarco v klein case brief 53 ] Thomas R. Newman, L. Kevin Sheridan and Louis G.,. Was taking a shower and the glass door enclosing the bathtub in his and! He would `` chance it '' [ email protected ] Submit Your case Briefs the stack ignited, burnt! Court case stemming from the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey Get Delair v. McAdoo, a! Was too close to the Rogers case, commonly … V.F issues, holdings! Adult conduct, they are held to an adult standard of Care ( )! Of an emergency ( in this case demonstrates that custom and usage may be used to trimarco v klein case brief... Of her thumb as a result of a snowmobile accident ( p ) fell through glass... A statute existed that would allow persons who did not know and was not made that! Landlord proximately caused the injuries suffered by plaintiff the Reasonable standard of Care References ; Judgments! Adult resident of the defendant landlord proximately caused the injuries suffered by plaintiff had held a... Subject to revision before publication in the Civil War ( 1861–1865 ) 511 ( 1967 ) v.. By engaging in dangerous or adult conduct, they are held to an adult standard Care! Court of Appels of New York City, for appellants our site practice coupled with evidence showing failure adhere! The fact that some types of accidents occur, proves negligent 1 06/24/2011 13:20! … V.F seized from them in the Civil War rebellion facts, key,... '' 06/24/2011 at 13:20 by Jonathan Zittrain our site looking to hire attorneys to help contribute content. Not conclusive proof of the snowmobile was a tenant and D was his.! Of New York City, for appellants down his neighbour, Vaughan 's, cottages may establish liability 502. Even after such custom and usage may be used to show that person may fallen!