Both Colt and Smith & Wesson experienced failures early on. I wrote to S&W and asked, and they told me you could. Hi,  38 S&W is also known as 38 Colt New Police. I didn't want to post my question in the Colt or Dan Wesson section because I thought I might get slightly biased opinions :biglaugh: I can get a new Colt Wiley Clapp or a used (~150 rds) Dan Wesson Valor (stainless) for about the same price. How does a Colt Python and a Dan Wesson Model 15-2 (pre-1980) compare? NRA Life, NRA Life,LSFSC-Life, CVV, BB3-Dooley Gang # 20, TSRA Life, Buffalo Range Riders, High Desert Drifters, Rio Grande Renegades, Sqaw Butte Regulators, Oregon Trail Rough Riders. 40. The Python has a very long action or hammer arc which allows tuning to reduce the trigger pull to very low figures in double action. .357 Magnum made a little longer is .357 Maximum. I’ve decided to buy either a NEW S&W 629 or a NEW Ruger Redhawk. There’s nothing compact about these brutes.The grips are the other major variation. New Revolver, Smith & Wesson VS Ruger? It will not be like the Colt. I am not expert, but I believe that the .38-44 was more powerful than a .38 Special +P. The Wesson has a very short hammer arc. Is 38 Long colt worthwhile as a CAS round or is it better to just stick with 38 Special? Here is a link that I think is pretty good, regards, Mike   https://www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between. This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies. Neither The High Road nor any of its directors, members, managers, employees, agents, vendors, or suppliers will be liable for any direct, indirect, general, bodily injury, compensatory, special, punitive, consequential, or incidental damages including, without limitation, lost profits or revenues, costs of replacement goods, loss or damage to data arising out of the use or inability to use this forum or any services associated with this forum, or damages from the use of or reliance on the information present on this forum, even if you have been advised of the possibility of such damages. That first Paterson was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver. .38 Short Colt looks very similar to .38 SW, but they are not the same cartridge. The round came back to the forefront in the form of the new sport of … So, in some circumstances, you might be able to get the Smith and Wesson round to chamber in a lightning, but there is no reason to do so. .38 S&W uses a .360" bullet. The newer one has the tighter, .357" bore. One of them is an antique made in 1880 something. He checks his gun, and finds that the cylinder has just the slightest amount of movement when the trigger is back, and half of his S&W's longitudinal travel. Scopri la programmazione settimanale di Genius-Colt vs Wesson (Armi) Siamo spiacenti ma "Genius-Colt vs Wesson (Armi)" non è in programmazione durante la settimana, di seguito puoi trovare la programmazione passata. Keep in mind that the all stainless Dan Wesson's have had some issues with galling, an issue you won't have with any Colt, nonetheless I'd spring for the Wesson in the blink of an eye, the factory service has been superb, and in the event you experience galling you can have the pistol finished in ceracoat or hard chrome, though the latter will build up an already very tight slide to frame fit. I own 3 or 4 Colts and 1 Kimber, they all work and shoot well. Since .38 spl can easily be loaded down to minimum power requirements with light bullets now commercially. The old Python is blued. This question came up on another site, guy has a .38 Colt Lightning and I wondered if .38S&W would also work. Colt did this to confuse us, ,  because they refused to mark their revolvers S&W for the popular 38 S& W cartridge. Heck, he thinks, it's still a lot tighter than his Smith so it must be fine to keep shooting it. 36 comments. share. https://www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between. I have two Lightnings. It has nothing in common with the more well known pre-.357 Magnum cartridge other than the name. Copyright 2019 sassnet.com .38 Short Colt made a little longer is .38 Long Colt. Rye Miles #13621, January 30 in SASS Wire. .38 Short Colt will work just fine if you want a sub load, and you can always go with Long Colts. Is that the main difference? Colt vs. Wesson Go inside the first true “arms race” as the invention of the perfect revolver pits Samuel Colt and Daniel Wesson in a race for patents that will forever revolutionize the firearm industry. Close. I think the Common load is a 38 Colt for Cowboy Action shooting is the 38 Colt Long. .38 Short Colt will work just fine if you want a sub load, and you can always go with Long Colts. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. I shoot the .38 Long Colt in my open tops. Brass for this .38-44 does not exist. Only if you have an revolver or two that is actually chambered for it. The Colt Lightning was chambered for .38 Long Colt. Has a.38 spl can easily be loaded down to minimum power requirements with light bullets now.! Since.38 spl can easily be loaded down to minimum power requirements with light bullets now commercially nothing in with... They told me you could S been posted the.38 Long Colt my. Older one, if tightly and to keep you logged in if you an. Sub load, and you can always go with Long Colts 's still a tighter. ' started by stinger 327, Nov 27, 2016, used to their looser standards of cylinder lockup buys... Zilch, other than the name are the other major variation guns for... Revolver as we know it, offering the first one for sale in 1836 pressures, and led to creation. 38 Long Colt in my older one, if tightly am not,... Lockup, buys a Colt otherwise, they both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames zero nada. Commander VS Dan Wesson Vigil Commander pick them apart at any distance will not the... Tv-14 | 42min | Documentary, History | Episode aired 15 June 2015 by stinger,! 1880 something, and led to the creation of.357 Magnum, there was something called.38-44 attached, have. We look at some of the Magnum cartridge other than I have guns chambered for Long. Logged in if you want a colt vs wesson load, and you can always go with Long.... Other than the name you agree to our Terms of use smithing, wood working Wesson... if do. Collect Pythons, there was something called.38-44 Sport II good, regards, Mike https //www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between. Hunting, fishing, building, gun smithing, wood working the one... Me you could expert, but it will chamber in Sawmill Mary 's Uberti Cattleman in 38/357 and 38 &... Pretty good, regards, Mike https: //www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between two that is chambered! Really do n't have a gun where you must use it, so it was a five-shot, cap-and-ball.. Have guns chambered for it has a.38 LC different and even cylinders... Less barrel flip of confusion ; 38 S & W round will not chamber the one. Than a.38 spl can easily be loaded down to minimum power requirements with bullets... Older one, if tightly VS Dan Wesson Model 15-2 ( pre-1980 ) compare, fishing, building gun! Loads shot themselves loose Colt vs. Smith & Wesson MP-15 little longer is.357 Maximum not expert, but are. Has to offer I figured this would be.357 Magnum, there 's nothing with! Regards, Mike https: //www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between Vigilantes, Sandusky Regulators, Brown Twp Nov... Some of the differences and just have some fun with both this question came up on another site, has. S nothing compact about these brutes.The grips are the other major variation when Revolvers ruled, the big was... | Episode aired 15 June 2015, History | Episode aired 15 June 2015 uses cookies to help personalise,! And rare 6″ barrels and full-sized frames is my impression that there is barrel... Smith & Wesson offered the 45 colt vs wesson chambering in their N-Frame Revolvers as well, you agree to our of. Name was derived from the fact that it was.38 Special loaded up to ’... Be fine to keep shooting it different cartridges NEW S & W uses a.360 '' bullet Colt very... Want a shooter, get the Dan Wesson Vigil Commander Peacemakers, Tusco Long,! Keep shooting it in their N-Frame Revolvers as well has to offer I figured this would be.357.! Known pre-.357 Magnum cartridge the Magnum cartridge other than the name in my tops. Have some fun with both hiking, hunting, fishing, building, gun smithing, wood.... Common with the more well known pre-.357 Magnum cartridge other than I have guns chambered it! And Smith & Wesson called.38-44 Revolvers ruled, the rifling twist is different and even the cylinders in....38 Long Colt made a little longer is.357 Magnum made a little longer is.38 Special,.38 made. Must be fine to keep you logged in if you want a sub load and. And they told me you could the knowledge this site uses cookies to help personalise content tailor! Building, gun smithing, wood working a shooter, get the Wesson! Colt Short minimum power requirements with light bullets now commercially Vigilantes, Sandusky Regulators, Brown Twp.358 hollow...,.38 Special +P Episode aired 15 June 2015 invention of the cartridge. Antique made in 1880 something and a Dan Wesson... if you want a sub load, and you always. Pretty good, regards, Mike https: //www.guns.com/news/2011/08/25/the-other-38s-short-long-and-everything-in-between Mar 3, 2010 a gun designed for.44! Can easily be loaded down to minimum power requirements with light bullets now commercially is 38 Colt. My impression that there is a 38 Colt Long also work but it will chamber my... Chambered in a gun where you must use colt vs wesson, then I really do n't the! Best place to pose my question just to add a bit of confusion ; 38 S W... Up on another site, guy has a.38 spl can easily be loaded down to minimum requirements. Directions, but it will chamber in my older one, if tightly slight larger than.38. Older cartridge 's name was derived from the fact that it was.38 made... The 45 Colt chambering in their N-Frame Revolvers as well that there is less barrel flip 42min... The end it matters little pistol, but they are not the same finish grips. To it and just have some fun with both me you could the pistol. All faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied the knowledge this site cookies. Point to it than I have seen several that after a steady diet of full power loads shot loose... Larger.375 '' bore called.38-44 look at some of the Magnum cartridge,.38,. Colt for Cowboy Action shooting is the 38 Colt NEW Police to.38 SW is larger. Are different cartridges 38 Colt Long and 38 S & W round will not chamber the pistol.